Guide: Statuses

Origin paper retracted

The original paper was retracted

The paper the first news reports were about has been retracted.

This entry has not yet been checked by a person. It was written by software from the sources it lists. What “checked by a person” means

In the records

The first news reports of the treatment were about a published paper, which this site calls the origin paper. The journal that published it has since issued a retraction notice, and the page lists that notice as a record, with its date and a link.

Any trials and other records found for the treatment stay on its page. They no longer set the status.

What it does not tell you

It does not say why the paper was retracted. Papers are retracted for honest error as well as for misconduct, and the notice itself is where the journal gives its reason.

It does not say that everything in the paper was wrong, or that later work by other groups is affected. A retraction is about one paper.

It does not say the treatment does not work. It says the paper that the first reports relied on is no longer part of the published record.

It is not this site’s judgement of the authors or the journal.

On this site

If the paper the first news reports were about has a retraction notice, the status is “Origin paper retracted”. This rule is applied first, before any trial or approval is considered. The rule: How a status is set

Sources

Something wrong on this page? Tell us what, and the source that shows it: Report an error (opens your mail)